The 48-Hour Follow-Up

Cristina Stensvaag
Feb 10
3 min read

Self-trust isn't built when you decide. It's built in the follow-up.

February 10, 2026

Originally published in One More Rep, a weekly newsletter for people managers who want to get better through practice. Subscribe here — it's free.

You made the decision. Now comes the hard part: staying present for what happens next. This rep is the 48-hour follow-up -- the moment where leaders either build self-trust or quietly avoid it.

Read

The Moment

It's Tuesday. On Monday you made a call: reassigned a project, changed a timeline, said no to a request. Done. Announced. Moving forward.

Now it's quiet.

You're wondering: Did I make the right call? Is anyone upset? Should I explain more?

So you wait. You avoid it. You see if anything breaks.

The Pattern

Here's the thing about self-trust: It isn’t built when you decide.It’s built in the hours after.

Most leaders think the hard part is making the decision.

It's not. The hard part is staying present for what happens next:

the feedback
the confusion
the silence

When you avoid the follow-up, you teach yourself that your decisions are fragile. That they need to be protected or hidden from scrutiny.

Self-trust compounds when you show up after the decision with curiosity.

Why This Matters

You don't learn to trust yourself by making perfect decisions. You trust yourself because you:

decide
watch what happens
use the data to get better

The follow-up is where the learning lives. It's where you discover:

what you missed
how people actually responded (vs. what you feared)
what needs adjusting
what you’d do differently next time

Leaders who skip the follow-up build self-protection, not self-trust. There's a difference.

Rep

This Week's Practice

Within 48 hours of making a decision this week, send a follow-up to the people it impacts.

The follow-up includes three things:

What you decided (clearly)
What you’re seeing so far (early observations)
What you’re open to (questions, feedback, adjustments)

Here's the template:

“Quick update on [the decision]. Here’s what I’m seeing so far: [one observation]. If you’re noticing something I’m missing or have questions, let me know by [specific time]. We’ll adjust if we need to.”

Your rep: Send at least one follow-up by Friday.

What to Notice

Resistance feels like:

“I’ll follow up next week when I have more data.”
Worry that checking in looks weak or uncertain.
The urge to explain or defend the decision.

It's working when:

You get useful information (not just “sounds good”).
You catch something early that would’ve become a bigger problem.
You feel less anxious because you’re actively monitoring.
People start proactively updating you.

Common Mistakes

Mistake #1: Turning the follow-up into an apology. “I know I made this call, but if it’s not working…” You’re not apologizing for deciding. You’re monitoring impact. Reframe: "Here’s what I decided. Here’s what I’m seeing. Here’s what I’m open to adjusting."

Mistake #2: Waiting for perfect data. "I'll follow up once I know how it's going..." 48 hours is the point. You won’t have all the data.

Mistake #3: Defending instead of listening. Someone pushes back and you immediately explain why you’re right. Curiosity before defense. Ask: "Tell me more about what you're seeing."

Reflect

After you've done your follow-ups this week, ask yourself:

Where did I feel the strongest urge to skip this?
What surprised me once I checked in?
What was I protecting by staying silent?
If I did this every week for a year, how would I lead differently?

Want a new leadership rep every week? Subscribe to One More Rep — it's free.

Cristina Stensvaag is co-founder of LeaderReps and creator of One More Rep, a weekly practice-based leadership newsletter for people managers.